Hi Ian,

Too bad that it was Boone after all...
I was so hoping they wouldn't do that. I was routing for Sayid to be the one. (not that I don't like Sayid, but I think it would've been more original)

All this time everyone was predicting it would be Boone, and it would be so 'logical' for it to be Boone because he wasn't explored too much and there was some obvious forshadowing. But too me that was just too obvious.
(Plus one of the hints said 'he's kinda hot', well I think you're very hot, so that ruled you out for me ;) lol)

But that aside, I really think it's an uncreative way of writing to write you out. It's like the 'easy way out'. Like if Boone was easy to miss and was an easy choice. I think it sucks and having you back for only flashbacks isn't enough. Maybe the island can magically heal you ;) haha. would be fun.

Now I wasn't Boone's biggest fan, but I had sympathy for him. Especially after Hearts & Minds. Oh and.. brilliant acting btw. You must have had a great bonding with Mathew Fox because the emotions between the two of you were great!

If you look back on it all, how do you feel about it?
Do you hate the fact that they killed Boone, or are you happy with the intense dying scenes?
Do you think you will be back, other then in the flashbacks?

All the best,
Rosely