Hello Gregg,

So last night was great! Yay! Although something that I really wanted to know wasn't answered.
Here's the hilarious part, I know you won't tell me either! However, knowing I've got so long to ponder this question, I have to give it a shot.

Incidents from the Losties pasts are repeated on the island. Not just situations where they make the same choice over and over (or finally figure out that's not working for them), I'm talking about "seeing" things that other people can see (Kate's horse) and hearing phrases repeated nearly verbatim that no one could have known about. For instance, Miss Klugh echoing Susan's attorney at the custody hearing? Hence my question... I won't hold my breath. Much.

This isn't coincidence, is it? They're being manipulated by an outside force of some kind, maybe Otherly in nature, possibly some weird feature of the anomaly that's being utilized or,... well, that's my best guess.

If you can't answer that, how about this: just how valid is my question?:cool:

I think it's a very valid question, but I don't think there is an outside force controling things. For this particular issue, I would use more narrative/story analysis to suss it out. Good luck pondering.